In January, Germany’s government and regional leaders agreed on a plan to phase out coal-fired power stations by 2038, a big achievement in the fight to lower carbon emissions. It seems to be a done deal- or is it?
The government initially pledged last year to shut down all coal-fired power stations but battled to secure support from the four states which have lignite (brown coal- the dirtiest coal) mines and coal-fired power plants: Saxony-Anhalt, North Rhine-Westphalia, and Brandenburg. There are also plans to open a new hard coal-fired power plant this year, muddying the government’s efforts to transition to a low- and eventually zero-carbon future.
The timetable for plant closures calls for the first 300MW unit to be taken out of service at the end of 2020, with another 900MW due to be shut down at the end of 2021. However, some of the biggest, most heavily polluting coal power stations will only be shut down in 2028 and 2029. The law prescribes equal annual reductions of lignite and hard coal capacity combined.
For hard coal plant operators, the law stipulates auctions for taking capacity off the grid until 2026. Afterward, there will be forced closures depending on the plants’ age and CO2 output. Operators can apply for compensation payments in auctions where the lowest bidders will be awarded. Hard coal plants in southern Germany will be exempt from the first round of auctions as they are considered to be more critical to supply security. Compensation payments for hard coal plants will be capped at 165 000 euros per megawatt in 2020 and then decline gradually.
The coal exit law also involves a compensation plan of 40 billion euros, which will target the coal states. Much of this money will go into new infrastructure projects for coal-dependent areas and retraining workers for new jobs there. Mines and utilities will also get compensation for lost production and there are plans to move government institutions and military installations to the affected regions to create jobs and revenue.
Separate from this fund, operators of heavily polluting coal-fired power plants in western Germany will receive 2.6 billion euros, while 1.75 billion euros will go to those with plants in the east. The move shows how expensive it is to stop burning the dirty fossil fuel and how politically motivated it is.
Coal currently powers about one-third of Germany’s electricity, and more than half of that relies on burning lignite, of which Germany is the world’s largest producer. The end date for burning lignite could be brought forward to 2035, depending on the progress made.
The government will conduct reviews in 2022, 2026, 2029, and 2032 to determine whether Germany can end coal-fired electricity generation in 2035.
Germany aims to generate at least 65% of its electricity from renewables by 2030.
Wind energy overtook lignite for the first time in 2019, producing 118 TWh, which is also a new record in total electricity production. However, with the number of new turbines falling to unprecedently low levels, Germany has received the worst rating of any wind power market, according to a survey conducted by Wind Energy Hamburg.
Criticisms of the Law
The plan has been met with some criticism. Environmental campaigners criticized the decision, saying that the agreement will see a new coal-fired power plant- Datteln 4- go into service later this year and allow for the expansion of the Garzweiler open-cast mine in western Germany.
Germany’s largest coal state, North Rhine- Westphalia, says that it cannot accept the coal exit law without major amendments, with the state’s regional economic minister, Andreas Pinkwart, asserting that the law treats hard coal power plants unfairly compared to lignite plants. The coal exit law differentiates between lignite and hard coal because a lignite phase-out will have a greater impact on mining regions and workers than the hard coal phase-out (Germany’s last hard coal mine closed in 2018).
Hard coal plant operators also object to the law, saying that the proposed compensation is insufficient and will result in thousands of job losses.
RELATED ARTICLES: Polluting Companies Likely To Lose Half |Finance Industry Takes a Stand for the Environment | How Honest is Green Finance? |Beware of Greenwashing in Finance |Finance Industry Takes a Stand for the Environment |The Innovation Springboard — SDG Finance Summit | How Will We Finance the New Deal for Nature?
Meanwhile, a German energy law firm has called the law ‘unconstitutional’ on the basis that the disparate treatment of hard coal and lignite operations violates the principles of equal treatment and the protection of property and trust in the law.
The Green Party, part of the opposition in the German federal parliament, also criticizes the law and says that it will work to shut down lignite plants earlier as well as prevent the new hard coal power plant, Datteln 4- which a report says will alone cause an additional 40 million tonnes of CO2 emissions- from going online. It proposes extending auctions until 2030 and compensating for decommissions during this time.
According to a report by the German Institute for Economic Research (DIW), Germany must abandon coal quicker than planned to comply with the Paris Agreement, by 2030 instead of the proposed 2038. It also calls for a speed-up of Germany’s renewable energy roll-out and tightening the country’s current target to lower emissions by 65% by 2030.
Concerns from Germans
According to a survey conducted by EuPD Research, 85% of Germans believe that the country’s coal exit will lead to significantly higher electricity prices, while 75% said that they expect the coal exit to lead to an increase in energy imports from outside Germany.
However, a recent study by energy think tank Agora Energiewende, found that the coal phase-out would have ‘very little’ impact on electricity prices. The study suggested that household customers would pay 0.4 euro cents more per kilowatt-hour in 2030, while energy-intensive industries could see decreased power costs.
How Difficult will the Transition to Renewables Be?
Andreas Schierenbeck, CEO of the power company, Uniper, has warned that Germany faces potential power shortages in the next few years as it removes nuclear and coal-fired power plants from the grid. While the company plans to move away from coal (with the exception of the Datteln 4 plant) by shutting down all of its lignite and hard coal plants by 2025 and focus on its natural gas business, Schierenbeck argues that Germany faces blackouts if it does not plan for enough back-up generation from fossil-fuel-fired plants even as it shifts to renewable energy, and he proposes that the German government should set up a system to fund and maintain fossil-fuel reserve capacity, similar to the UK.
However, according to the country’s grid agency, BNetzA, this isn’t a concern. It says that power blackouts are increasingly caused by extreme weather events rather by the transition to renewable energies. In fact, a government report last year found that the German electricity supply would remain ‘extremely secure’ by international standards, even as the country simultaneously phases out coal and nuclear power.
The parliament hearing on the coal exit law was scheduled for March 25, however, it was postponed due to the COVID-19 pandemic. It is unknown when the hearing has been rescheduled, but the government aims to pass final legislation in the first half of this year (2020).
Energy industry federation BEE says that parts of the 40 billion euros earmarked for the coal phase-out should be channeled into a green stimulus package to help energy companies during the coronavirus outbreak. The organization’s head, Simone Peter, calls for ‘at least’ 4.3 billion euros to be put into investment premiums as well as to remove other existing hurdles for wind, solar, and bioenergy to stabilize renewable energy companies.
This article has been posted on Earth.org as well. Click here to see it.
In the cover picture: A mine. Photo Credit: Rab Lawrence via Flickr.
Editor’s Note: The opinions expressed here by Impakter.com columnists are their own, not those of Impakter.com