Impakter
  • News
    • Culture
      • Art
      • Cinema
      • Entertainment
      • Literature
      • Music
      • Photography
    • Style
      • Architecture
      • Design
      • Fashion
      • Foodscape
      • Lifestyle
    • Society
      • Business
      • Foreign Affairs & Politics
      • Health
      • Tech
      • Science
      • Start-up
    • Impact
      • Eco Life
      • Circular Economy
      • COP26
      • CityLife
        • Copenhagen
        • San Francisco
        • Seattle
        • Sydney
      • Sustainability Series
        • SDGs Series
        • Shape Your Future
        • 2030: Dream or Reality
      • Philanthropy
        • United Nations
        • NGO & Charities
        • Essays
  • Environment
  • Sustainability Index
  • Partners
  • About
    • Team
      • Global Leaders
      • Contributors
      • Write for Impakter
        • Republishing Content
        • Permissions and Copyright
        • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Culture
      • Art
      • Cinema
      • Entertainment
      • Literature
      • Music
      • Photography
    • Style
      • Architecture
      • Design
      • Fashion
      • Foodscape
      • Lifestyle
    • Society
      • Business
      • Foreign Affairs & Politics
      • Health
      • Tech
      • Science
      • Start-up
    • Impact
      • Eco Life
      • Circular Economy
      • COP26
      • CityLife
        • Copenhagen
        • San Francisco
        • Seattle
        • Sydney
      • Sustainability Series
        • SDGs Series
        • Shape Your Future
        • 2030: Dream or Reality
      • Philanthropy
        • United Nations
        • NGO & Charities
        • Essays
  • Environment
  • Sustainability Index
  • Partners
  • About
    • Team
      • Global Leaders
      • Contributors
      • Write for Impakter
        • Republishing Content
        • Permissions and Copyright
        • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
Impakter
No Result
View All Result
Home Society Politics & Foreign Affairs

Turn in Thy Neighbour — Hong Kong’s New Informers’ Hotline

byTará McKerr
November 12, 2020
in Politics & Foreign Affairs, Society
Graffiti of spy camera on wall
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

On Nov. 6, it was reported that Hong Kong’s ‘Informers’ Hotline’ received over 1,000 reports within hours of police launching the initiative on social media. Day two saw numbers soar beyond 2,500.

The ‘National Security Department Reporting Hotline’ has been established to allow civilians to report matters of ‘national security-related intelligence’ via the avenues of email, SMS and China’s answer to WhatsApp — WeChat. It comes also with the added promise of anonymity for the reporting party, not to mention accepting photographs and video footage too.

This follows the colourful contextual backdrop of Hong Kong’s recent political history. The world watched as Hongkongers fought China’s extradition bill, with a 5-pronged set of demands. China responded with the Hong Kong National Security law, the particulars of which were kept secret until after it passed.

Impakter Banner

As with the new informers’ hotline, the dangers of China’s measures as they apply to Hong Kong are hidden in-between the lines. It is the broadness of the guidelines, and the boundlessness of the boundaries, that makes Hong Kong an increasingly worrying land for its citizens. What is more, the scope of such measures apply to both permanent and non-permanent residents alike.

The term ‘national security threat’ is synonymous with a ‘catch-all’ for offences against the mainland. This is a concern expressed by Amnesty International and spanning through to the United Nations Human Rights office, who share the belief that such broad terminology can lead to ‘discriminatory or arbitrary interpretation and enforcement which could undermine human rights protection.’ The fact these accusations can be retrospective, only deepens these sentiments.

No one will feel safe, even foreigners.

— Eric Cheung, Principal Lecturer of Law at University of Hong Kong

Whilst headlines have exploded with outrage regarding the reports, there is a resounding appetite in Hong Kong for the pro-democracy movement — waging against the overarching arm of the mainland. Whilst some sources suspect prank calls as a rationale for the surge, it has also been suggested that because very little can constitute an offence, reports are being made for trivial matters.

The vast majority of Hong Kong is anti-mainland, but it only takes a very vocal minority to reach 1,000.

— HK Teacher, Anonymous Source #1

A source holds that rhetoric from the liaison office, police, and HK government has only plunged division further. When Hongkongers are painted as ‘law-breaking anarchists’ for posting subversion-flavoured Facebook posts or supporting outwardly pro-democracy businesses, seeds of polarisation are sewn. By default, very few actions of free political expression escape the purview of ‘national security related intelligence’.

People are worried that neighbours may use previous instances or disagreements to snitch on innocent people who they simply do not like.

— HK Teacher, Anonymous Source #2

As legislator for the Democratic party, James To, has expressed, this will “undermine the trust between people. Much of the reports will be related to the individuals’ political opinions.” The backlash  surrounding the hotline sings a reminiscent tune of the Chinese Communist party’s ‘model of relying on grassroots informants.’

There are tones here that that give a taste of Déjà vu. It’s as if 1930’s Russia, under Soviet rule is whispering in the background. One only has to look back to the case of  Pavlic Morozov, the teenage Soviet who turned in his own father for hoarding grain, before being put to death by the locals.  Neighbour turning against neighbour, protections for state loyalty- Once this mode of stitchery has been established, it is worrying to think of how far it can go. The Orwell, ‘1984’, Big Brother comparisons are difficult to shake here too.

Hong Kong's nathan road during 2019 protests.
In the Photo: Moment from the Hong Kong protest in November, 2019. Photo Credit: Kon Karampelas

Since the 2019 protests, much else has gone on in the world, leaving many Hongkongers feeling as if they have been left behind. Meanwhile, measures like the hotline have encroached upon areas of everyday life. Teachers report restrictive and pro-mainland changes to the curriculum.


RELATED ARTICLES: Can China’s Rise To Power Be Peaceful? Here Is What Political Theories Tell Us | Assessing China: For Worse or Better | The Extradition Bill: The Beginning of the End for Hong Kong? Everything Western Media Isn’t Telling You About Hong Kong | If We Burn, You Burn With Us: Hong Kong Protests Escalate

One source even describes new rules in their local comedy club. Things not to mention:

  1. National Security Law
  2. HK independence
  3. Chinese communist government

This one hit them hard. Comedy clubs are, after all, international bastions of free speech. Once a safe space for open dialogue; now developing undertones of do’s and don’ts.

A sign of the times presents itself in that all sources mentioned in this article have asked to remain anonymous. In fact, when asked for an interview, one even responded with, ‘Yes, no problem. Just let me go onto my VPN before we talk.’ Doesn’t that just sum it up?

Yet, with neighbour snitching on neighbour for Covid-19 related violations, upon government advice, right here in the UK — we might take a moment to reflect, before throwing Western stones.

In the cover picture: A painting on a wall warning visitors about video surveillance. Photo Credit: Tobias Tullius.


Editor’s Note: The opinions expressed here by Impakter.com contributors are their own, not those of  Impakter.com

Tags: APACchinaHong KongHuman rightsInformersPoliticssurveillance
Previous Post

Why the FSO Nabarima Remains an Oil Spill Threat for the Caribbean

Next Post

Intersectionality and the School-to-Prison Pipeline

Tará McKerr

Tará McKerr

Tará is an Irish polymath with specific interests in the environment, human rights, and finance. With a law degree and a year of legal experience under her belt, she worked for an NGO in Hong Kong, before entering financial consultancy and developing a passion for green finance.

Related Posts

Our World Is Changing Ever Faster: What This Means For Our Survival
Impact

Our World Is Changing Ever Faster: What This Means For Our Survival

February 4, 2023
A photo demonstrating the loss and damage caused by flooding
Climate Change

Climate Loss & Damage: What Gaps Will the New Fund Fill?

February 4, 2023
Coca Is Not Cocaine: The Truth Behind the Sacred South American Coca Leaf
Agriculture

Coca Is Not Cocaine: The Truth Behind the Sacred South American Coca Leaf

February 3, 2023
Next Post
Intersectionality and the School-to-Prison Pipeline

Intersectionality and the School-to-Prison Pipeline

Recent News

Our World Is Changing Ever Faster: What This Means For Our Survival

Our World Is Changing Ever Faster: What This Means For Our Survival

February 4, 2023
A photo demonstrating the loss and damage caused by flooding

Climate Loss & Damage: What Gaps Will the New Fund Fill?

February 4, 2023
Coca Is Not Cocaine: The Truth Behind the Sacred South American Coca Leaf

Coca Is Not Cocaine: The Truth Behind the Sacred South American Coca Leaf

February 3, 2023
impakter-logo-light

Impakter informs you through the eco news site and empowers your sustainable lifestyle with its eco products marketplace.

Visit here IMPAKTER ECO for your eco products needs.

Registered Office Address

32 Lots Road, London
SW10 0QJ, United Kingdom


IMPAKTER Limited

Company number: 10806931

Impakter is a publication that is identified by the following International Standard Serial Number (ISSN) is the following 2515-9569 (Printed) and 2515-9577 (online – Website).


Office Hours - Monday to Friday

9.30am - 5.00pm CEST


Email

stories [at] impakter.com

About Us

  • Team
  • Contributors
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Partners

By Audience

  • Lifestyle
  • Green Finance
  • Culture
  • Society
  • Style
  • Impact

Impakter Platforms

  • Media
  • Index

© 2023 IMPAKTER. All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • ECO Products Shop – Try now!
  • Culture
  • Style
  • Society
  • Impact
  • Sustainability Index
  • About
    • Partners
    • Team
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy

© 2023 IMPAKTER. All rights reserved.

Impakter.com uses cookies to enhance your experience when visiting the website and to serve you with advertisements that might interest you. By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.