Shop on Impakter Eco
  • Women
  • Men
  • Kids
  • Beautycare
  • Home & Living
  • Food & Drinks
  • Pets
Impakter
Shop on Eco Shop
  • Shop Eco
  • Culture
    • Art
    • Cinema
    • Entertainment
    • Literature
    • Music
    • Photography
  • Style
    • Architecture
    • Design
    • Fashion
    • Foodscape
    • Lifestyle
  • Society
    • Business
    • Environment
    • Foreign Affairs & Politics
    • Health
    • Tech
    • Science
    • Start-up
  • Impact
    • Eco Life
    • Circular Economy
    • COP26
    • CityLife
      • Copenhagen
      • San Francisco
      • Seattle
      • Sydney
    • Sustainability Series
      • SDGs Series
      • Shape Your Future
      • 2030: Dream or Reality
    • Philanthropy
      • United Nations
      • NGO & Charities
      • Essays
    • Your Voice
      • Empower Earth
      • Empower Equality
  • SUSTAINABILITY INDEX
  • Startup-Hub
    • Companies
    • Investors
    • Organisations
    • Jobs
    • Events
  • Partners
  • About
    • Team
    • Global Leaders
    • Contributors
    • Write for Impakter
    • IMPAKTER Italy
    • Republishing Content
    • Permissions and Copyright
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
Impakter
No Result
View All Result
Home Society Health

Lesbian Parents Are Refused Medical Care – The Story

Providenza Loera RoccobyProvidenza Loera Rocco
April 12, 2017
in Health
bioethics, Impakter
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

I will remember that I remain a member of society, with special obligations to all my fellow human beings, those sound of mind and body as well as the infirm

–Hippocratic Oath

Conscientious objection in health care “is the refusal to perform a legal role or responsibility because of moral or other personal beliefs.”

In February 2015, six-day-old baby Bay was refused treatment by a Michigan pediatrician, Dr. Vesa Roi, because Bay’s parents are lesbians. Roi realized she could not care for the baby after praying about it. While the family was welcome in the office generally, Roi would not be able to care for baby Bay, or “develop the personal patient-doctor relationship that I normally do with my patients” because of the sexual orientation of Bay’s parents.

doctor

PHOTO CREDIT: Pexels

In April 2016, a law passed in Mississippi, the Protecting Freedom of Conscience from Government Discrimination Act, making it legal for physicians and therapists to refuse to care for patients on religious grounds. Indeed, the Mississippi law makes it “expressly legal for doctors, psychologists, and counselors to opt out of any procedure or choose not to take on any patient if doing so would compromise their conscience.”


Related Article: OP-ED: BOUTIQUE MEDICINE IN THE MODERN WORLD


Similarly, a 2016 law passed in Tennessee makes it legal for counselors to refuse to provide counseling or therapy services based on the counselor’s religious convictions. In January 2017, a federal district judge, Reed O’Connor, of Fort Worth, Texas, blocked regulations which prohibited insurers, doctors, or hospitals from discriminating against transgender patients or women who have had an abortion.

Especially in a post-Hobby Lobby climate, these laws are not out of the ordinary. In fact most states have conscience clauses. For example, in Oregon, a conscience clause permits a doctor to refuse to participate in physician-aid-in-dying, which is legal in that state, based on the physician’s personal beliefs. Some conscience clauses are specifically for pharmacists who might refuse to fill a certain prescription based on moral or religious grounds.

In 2009, the American Academy of Pediatrics Committee on Bioethics issued a statement upholding the professional right of conscience for pediatricians. Similarly, protections are upheld for physicians who will not perform sterilization or abortions due to religious convictions. And physicians who cite the right of conscience in refusing to perform a certain procedure or see a patient are rarely challenged on this particular basis. 

Conscientious objection in health care has particular effects, effects that conscientious objection in, say, education or other parts of civil society simply do not carry: “Conscientious objection in health care always affects someone else’s health or access to care because the refusal interrupts the delivery of health services. Therefore, conscientious objection in health care always has a social dimension and cannot be framed solely as an issue of individual rights or beliefs.” 

So, imagine going to see a doctor, but being denied treatment because you are gay, or black, or white, or not gay, or because you are Jewish or Christian or Muslim or atheist. Imagine allowing your doctor to pray about whether or not to care for you and that being the decision you have to accept. Imagine being asked what your sexual orientation or religious beliefs are before entering an ambulance. Or, even worse, imagine, as in the case of innocent Baby Bay, a physician refuses to see you because of your parents’ sexual orientation? Imagine having to give a detailed family history on the sexual orientation of your mom or dad before a physician will enter into a physician-patient relationship with you.

doctor

PHOTO CREDIT: Pexels

This is a very scary thought, and a slippery slope is easy to imagine. Conscience clauses for physicians allow personal values to trump professional norms and values and create a space where individual beliefs trump a professional duty of care. If physicians want to keep their status as ethical professionals, they must adhere to ethical standards of care, standards that are deep-rooted in the Hippocratic oath, an oath that calls upon them to care for all my fellow human beings, those of sound mind as well as the infirm. The AMA Code of Ethics calls upon physicians to be dedicated to providing competent medical care, with compassion and respect for human dignity and rights, regarding responsibility to the patient as paramount.

This is part of the important social contract that doctors have with their patients. Discrimination has no place in health care, and runs contrary to the special obligations that a physician has to her fellow human beings who fall under her care.  An ability to care for and work with individuals from diverse backgrounds is just as important of a skill as a physician’s ability to master anatomy and physiology. If a physician cannot ethically and compassionately work with diverse populations, she should perhaps not practice medicine and find a job where professional and ethical standards are less demanding. Conscience must not become a coverup for prejudicial, unjust, or unethical health care.


Recomended Reading: THE TELEMEDICINE DILEMMA


EDITOR’S NOTE: THE OPINIONS EXPRESSED HERE BY IMPAKTER.COM COLUMNISTS ARE THEIR OWN, NOT THOSE OF IMPAKTER.COM
Tags: AMA Code of EthicsAmerican Academy of Pediatrics Committee on BioethicsBaby Bayconscientious objectionDr. Vesa Roiduty of careHippocratic oathHobby Lobby ClimateImpakerJudge Reed O'ConnorProtecting Freedom of Conscience from Government Discrimination ActProvidenza (Enza) Rocco
Previous Post

Going to the United States? Your Devices Might Be Checked

Next Post

A Poem By Michael Juliani

Providenza Loera Rocco

Providenza Loera Rocco

Enza is an Assistant Professor of Bioethics in the Center for Bioethics, Urban Health, and Policy, at the Lewis Katz School of Medicine at Temple University, where she also serves as the Assistant Director of the MA Urban Bioethics Program. She specializes in urban bioethics and legal and ethical issues in end-of-life care. Enza earned her master's in Social Work and her master's in Bioethics from the University of Pennsylvania, and she earned her law degree from Temple University Beasley School of Law. Enza also teaches at Simmons School of Social Work where she teaches courses in social policy. Additionally, she serves on the Hospice and Palliative Nurses Foundation Board of Directors. She is the proud mom of Joseph, age 2 and Nicoletta, age 1. She lives with her husband, kids, and two dogs in Philadelphia.

Related Posts

World Economic Forum 2022: Not All Major Issues Adressed
Health

World Economic Forum 2022: Not All Major Issues Adressed

May 24, 2022
When “Feeling Nothing” Is Not Good Enough to Survive
Health

When “Feeling Nothing” Is Not Good Enough to Survive

May 22, 2022
New Menstrual Leave and Abortion Laws in Spain: Are Reforms a Gain for Women?
Editor's Pick

New Menstrual Leave and Abortion Laws in Spain: Are Reforms a Gain for Women?

May 13, 2022
Next Post
light-person-woman-fire-sweater

A Poem By Michael Juliani

Please login to join discussion

Recent News

Hundreds of Climate Activists Protest Against TotalEnergies’ New Fossil Fuel Projects

Hundreds of Climate Activists Protest Against TotalEnergies’ New Fossil Fuel Projects

May 26, 2022
Texas School Shooting Claims 21 Lives, Sparking Calls for Gun Reform

Texas School Shooting Claims 21 Lives, Sparking Calls for Gun Reform

May 26, 2022
Sustainable Malmö: Six Short Films Demonstrate How Cities Can Become More Sustainable

Sustainable Malmö: Six Short Films Demonstrate How Cities Can Become More Sustainable

May 26, 2022
impakter-logo-light

Impakter informs you through the eco news site and empowers your sustainable lifestyle with its eco products marketplace.

Visit here IMPAKTER ECO for your eco products needs.

Registered Office Address

32 Lots Road, London
SW10 0QJ, United Kingdom


IMPAKTER Limited

Company number: 10806931

Impakter is a publication that is identified by the following International Standard Serial Number (ISSN) is the following 2515-9569 (Printed) and 2515-9577 (online – Website).


Office Hours - Monday to Friday

9.30am - 5.00pm CEST


Email

stories [at] impakter.com

About Us

  • Team
  • Contributors
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Partners

By Audience

  • Lifestyle
  • Green Finance
  • Culture
  • Society
  • Style
  • Impact

Impakter Platforms

  • Media
  • Up
  • Index
  • Eco for Sellers
  • Impakter Pro

© 2022 IMPAKTER. All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Culture
  • Style
  • Society
  • Impact
  • ECO Products Shop – Try now!
  • INDEX – Sustainability Index
  • UP – Startup Hub
  • About
    • Partners
    • Team
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
Impakter.com uses cookies to enhance your experience when visiting the website and to serve you with advertisements that might interest you. By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.