Impakter
  • News
    • Culture
      • Art
      • Cinema
      • Entertainment
      • Literature
      • Music
      • Photography
    • Style
      • Architecture
      • Design
      • Fashion
      • Foodscape
      • Lifestyle
    • Society
      • Business
      • Foreign Affairs & Politics
      • Health
      • Tech
      • Science
      • Start-up
    • Impact
      • Eco Life
      • Circular Economy
      • COP26
      • CityLife
        • Copenhagen
        • San Francisco
        • Seattle
        • Sydney
      • Sustainability Series
        • SDGs Series
        • Shape Your Future
        • 2030: Dream or Reality
      • Philanthropy
        • United Nations
        • NGO & Charities
        • Essays
  • Environment
  • Sustainability Index
  • Partners
  • About
    • Team
      • Global Leaders
      • Contributors
      • Write for Impakter
        • Republishing Content
        • Permissions and Copyright
        • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • Culture
      • Art
      • Cinema
      • Entertainment
      • Literature
      • Music
      • Photography
    • Style
      • Architecture
      • Design
      • Fashion
      • Foodscape
      • Lifestyle
    • Society
      • Business
      • Foreign Affairs & Politics
      • Health
      • Tech
      • Science
      • Start-up
    • Impact
      • Eco Life
      • Circular Economy
      • COP26
      • CityLife
        • Copenhagen
        • San Francisco
        • Seattle
        • Sydney
      • Sustainability Series
        • SDGs Series
        • Shape Your Future
        • 2030: Dream or Reality
      • Philanthropy
        • United Nations
        • NGO & Charities
        • Essays
  • Environment
  • Sustainability Index
  • Partners
  • About
    • Team
      • Global Leaders
      • Contributors
      • Write for Impakter
        • Republishing Content
        • Permissions and Copyright
        • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
Impakter
No Result
View All Result
Home Society Politics & Foreign Affairs

Poland Takes Steps To Unlock EU Billions: Too Little?

The European Union blocked pandemic recovery funds to force Poland to restore the rule of law; to access the funds, Poland walked back some of its controversial judicial reforms but that may not be enough

byOlivia Sophia Eggleston
January 16, 2023
in Politics & Foreign Affairs
Polish government Takes Steps To Unlock EU Billions
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

In late 2015, the right-wing populist party, Law and Justice (in Polish Prawo i Sprawiedliwość PiS),  came to power in Poland. Almost immediately, the party began pushing for judicial reforms, claiming these were overdue in light of a system supposedly riddled with communist-era corruption. 

The claims were baseless of course, as the Polish judicial system had already been reformed years before to allow Poland to join the European Union (which it did in 2004): Poland signed an Accession Treaty to join the Union as all new members do, showing a clean slate (no corruption!) and adherence to democratic values and principles, including the separation of the three powers: executive, judicial and parliamentary.

According to the European Commission, the PiS-led reforms placed Poland’s judiciary “under the political control of the ruling majority,” thus stripping it of its independence and undermining the rule of law. As a result, “serious questions are raised about the effective application of EU law.” 

One of the more controversial reforms involved lowering the retirement age for Supreme Court justices from 70 to 65, but leaving the president with a discretionary power to prolong the mandates of judges of his choosing. 

This was widely perceived as a ploy to replace acting judges with new ones whose loyalties, interests and ideologies are aligned with the PiS. In addition, the retirement age for women judges was five years lower than men’s. 

The European Court of Justice has ruled various elements of the judicial reforms as illegal under EU law.

The EU has been in dispute with Poland over the reforms for the past few years, urging Poland to realign itself with EU standards of democracy and judicial independence. 

The row was exacerbated in 2019 when Poland established the Disciplinary Chamber Law, an extremely controversial bill that enables the government to control the judiciary, as the Disciplinary Chamber is given the power to evaluate judges and prosecutors and dismiss them at will.

In 2021, the European Court of Justice, ruled the Disciplinary Chamber illegal because it undermined judicial independence.


Related articles: The collapse of Democracy in Poland: What it Means for Europe | Poland Doubles Down in its Fight Against European Law | EU Commission to Unblock COVID Recovery Funds for Poland | Poland Threatens  European Rule of Law: Is EU at Risk? |

But instead of respecting the ECJ’s ruling, Poland endeavoured to challenge the primacy of EU law in another court case. Ultimately, this led to the European Commission delaying Poland’s designated pandemic-recovery payout. 

The fund has remained frozen, its release contingent on a roll-back of Poland’s controversial judicial reforms. The European Commission has linked the disbursement of cash to Poland’s meeting of set ‘milestones’, a plan which Ursula von der Leyen signed off on in 2021. 

This decision was widely criticised as too lenient towards Poland and many called for a far stauncher defence of democratic and rule-of-law values. 

Vĕra Jourová, the commissioner for values and transparency, told POLITICO that the milestones in question would “build on the ECJ’s ruling, meaning Poland’s disciplinary chamber needs to stop all action, and Warsaw should reform the chamber.”

Needing the money to improve chances of reelection, along with the building pressure of crises such as the Ukraine war, president Andrzej Duda has become increasingly desperate to access the funds. 

In May 2022, Duda proposed legislation which he claimed met the prescribed milestones, but it was generally seen as a “sham” designed to unlock the cash flow which didn’t actually do much to remedy the issues at hand.

Last Wednesday, the first stage of a new bill was approved in Poland’s parliament, and if the EU accepts it as meeting the requirements it would grant Poland access to €36 billion in loans and grants from the recovery fund.

Eurosceptics in the parliament rejected the bill, but they were in a serious minority. Sebastian Kaleta, a member of “United Poland,” PiS’ coalition partner, described the bill as “a capitulation, and a prelude to more blackmail by the EU.”

The bill would move judicial review proceedings from the controversial Disciplinary Chamber to the Supreme Administrative Court, which is seen as more independent. 

It would also remove sanctions currently in place which effectively censor judges from speaking out against or even questioning the judicial reforms.

Doubts remain with regards to the adequacy of these measures. Daniel Freud, a Green party German member of European Parliament, said the bill would not “substantially solve the issue of disciplining judges for political reasons in Poland. I still don’t see the milestones to be fulfilled. Releasing payments to Poland in this situation is not justified.” 

Whether government control of the judiciary will tangibly be reduced remains to be seen. Importantly, the EU cannot afford Poland any leniency with regards to undermining the rule of law, democracy and judicial independence – values on which EU membership is contingent. It is expected that the Commission will remain vigilant in its assessment of the adequacy of Poland’s proposed “solutions.”


Editor’s Note: The opinions expressed here by the authors are their own, not those of Impakter.com — In the Featured Photo: A Polish National Assembly meeting. Featured Photo Credit: Wikimedia Commons.

Tags: Blocked FundsEUEuropean UnionPoland
Previous Post

On ‘Presencing’: Interview With Dr. Otto Scharmer

Next Post

Why Are 6,000 Climate Protestors Marching to a Remote German Hamlet?

Olivia Sophia Eggleston

Olivia Sophia Eggleston

Having recently graduated from University College London with a bachelor of law, Olivia is embarking on a career in journalism. Of an Assyrian, German and English background, she was raised in the Hague and is now based in London. Her love of writing extends beyond journalism to poetry and short stories.

Related Posts

‘Who’s Who’ in the European Parliament Corruption Scandal
Politics & Foreign Affairs

‘Who’s Who’ in the European Parliament Corruption Scandal

February 1, 2023
COP28 president oil
Climate Change

Oil Baron Elected President-Designate of COP28: How Has the UN Allowed This? 

January 30, 2023
The Apocalypse Is Just 90 Seconds Away, Says the Doomsday Clock
Politics & Foreign Affairs

The Apocalypse Is Just 90 Seconds Away, Says the Doomsday Clock

January 30, 2023
Next Post
Lützerath coal mine

Why Are 6,000 Climate Protestors Marching to a Remote German Hamlet?

Recent News

Talking to strangers can make us happier.

Talking to Strangers Makes Us Happier — Science Shows

February 1, 2023
UK seas whales

Good Sign for Ocean Recovery: Whales May be Coming Back to the UK

February 1, 2023
‘Who’s Who’ in the European Parliament Corruption Scandal

‘Who’s Who’ in the European Parliament Corruption Scandal

February 1, 2023
impakter-logo-light

Impakter informs you through the eco news site and empowers your sustainable lifestyle with its eco products marketplace.

Visit here IMPAKTER ECO for your eco products needs.

Registered Office Address

32 Lots Road, London
SW10 0QJ, United Kingdom


IMPAKTER Limited

Company number: 10806931

Impakter is a publication that is identified by the following International Standard Serial Number (ISSN) is the following 2515-9569 (Printed) and 2515-9577 (online – Website).


Office Hours - Monday to Friday

9.30am - 5.00pm CEST


Email

stories [at] impakter.com

About Us

  • Team
  • Contributors
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact
  • Partners

By Audience

  • Lifestyle
  • Green Finance
  • Culture
  • Society
  • Style
  • Impact

Impakter Platforms

  • Media
  • Index

© 2023 IMPAKTER. All rights reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • ECO Products Shop – Try now!
  • Culture
  • Style
  • Society
  • Impact
  • Sustainability Index
  • About
    • Partners
    • Team
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy

© 2023 IMPAKTER. All rights reserved.

Impakter.com uses cookies to enhance your experience when visiting the website and to serve you with advertisements that might interest you. By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.