One of Milton Friedman’s most influential claims is that inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon. This interpretation has profoundly influenced contemporary economic thought, helping to establish the idea that price stability depends to a decisive extent on money supply management.
The monetarist argument rests on an intuitive principle: when the money supply persistently grows faster than real output, inflationary pressures are likely to emerge. Money represents purchasing power, which ultimately depends on the availability of goods and services in the economy. Yet, while Friedman’s framework explicitly acknowledges the role of real output, its primary emphasis remains on monetary dynamics, with productive capacity largely determined by factors such as capital, labour and technology.
This raises a broader question: If price stability depends not only on the amount of money in circulation but also on the goods and services available, should greater attention be paid to how productive capacity is created and expanded?
Economic equilibrium reflects the interaction between monetary conditions and the economy’s productive capacity. When monetary expansion is not accompanied by a corresponding increase in output, inflationary pressures may arise. Conversely, an expansion of productive capacity can allow an economy to accommodate growing demand without generating the same upward pressure on prices.
Importantly, inflationary pressures can also originate on the supply side. A decline in output or an increase in production costs may drive prices higher even in the absence of an initial monetary expansion. Although temporary price increases should be distinguished from persistent inflation, such developments highlight the importance of real economic conditions in shaping price dynamics.
Monetary stability, therefore, cannot be understood purely in terms of money supply, as it also depends on the economy’s ability to produce the goods and services that money can purchase. These two dimensions are not independent: through credit allocation, the financial system can influence investment decisions and, ultimately, the development of future productive capacity.
This tension was evident in late 2023, when an ECB survey identified higher interest rates and weaker financing needs for fixed investment as the main drivers of declining corporate loan demand.
Credit creates money, but it can also help create output
In modern economies, a substantial share of money consists of bank deposits. When a commercial bank grants a loan, it generally creates a corresponding deposit, increasing the amount of bank money available; conversely, loan repayments reduce the stock of bank deposits. Money creation, therefore, does not depend exclusively on issuing banknotes or on central bank operations: commercial banks also play a central role, although their lending activities remain subject to capital requirements, regulation, funding conditions and monetary policy.
This mechanism raises an important question: beyond the quantity of money created, does it also matter how credit is allocated across the economy?
To illustrate this point, consider two loans of equal value. The first is granted to purchase an existing asset, without directly changing productive capacity, while the second enables a company to build a factory, purchase machinery or develop an innovative technology.
Although both loans initially create the same amount of bank money, their potential effects on the real economy may differ substantially. In fact, in the second case, credit can support the formation of new capital and the expansion of the supply of goods and services, potentially increasing the productive capacity available in subsequent years. Moreover, the importance of credit for productivity is supported by a BIS study estimating that the 2007–2009 credit contraction accounted for roughly one-quarter of Italy’s subsequent productivity slowdown.
The distinction, however, is not absolute. Productive investments may fail to deliver the expected returns, while financing existing assets can also generate economic benefits. Moreover, the effects of credit allocation on prices are neither immediate nor automatic: investment may initially stimulate demand, whereas its contribution to productive capacity typically emerges over time. Nevertheless, a fundamental distinction remains: two monetary expansions of identical size can have different effects on the structure of the economy and its growth potential.
This perspective suggests that monetarist analysis could be enriched by considering not only the quantity of money created, but also how credit is allocated and its potential to foster investment and expand productive capacity.
Time as a fundamental dimension of investment
The relationship between credit and production cannot be fully understood without considering the role of time. While consumption primarily satisfies immediate needs, investment involves committing resources today with the expectation of generating economic benefits in the future.
A company investing in new machinery, for instance, incurs an immediate cost but may benefit from increased efficiency and productive capacity for years to come. Similarly, infrastructure projects, such as railway networks or energy systems, can support economic activity over much longer periods.
Investment therefore transforms resources available in the present into productive capacity that can continue generating value in the future, a feature that distinguishes capital accumulation from a mere act of consumption.
However, an investment’s long-term value depends not simply on how long an asset lasts, but on its ability to remain economically useful. The Colosseum, for instance, has survived for nearly two millennia, and its function has evolved accordingly: from hosting public spectacles to generating cultural and tourism-related benefits. Similarly, modern infrastructure may remain physically intact while becoming technologically obsolete or economically inefficient.
Maintaining productive capacity therefore requires more than the initial investment. Maintenance, technological adaptation and, when necessary, the conversion of existing assets are essential to preserving an investment’s economic value.
This temporal dimension has important implications for credit allocation. Financing productive investment can stimulate demand in the short run while potentially expanding supply over time. The extent of this contribution, however, depends on the investment’s productivity, durability and capacity to adapt to changing economic conditions.
Economic policy should therefore consider not only how much investment takes place, but also whether it creates lasting productive value and at what cost that value can be sustained.
Beyond demand: can investment contribute to price stability?
Inflation is often approached as a problem of excessive demand; yet prices can also rise when an economy struggles to produce enough to meet that same demand. This raises a further question: can strengthening productive capacity contribute to price stability?
Productive investment offers one possible answer: by improving energy efficiency, adopting new technologies or removing logistical bottlenecks, firms can increase output without a proportional rise in production costs. Over time, such improvements may ease supply constraints and reduce the pressure that rising demand places on prices.
Of course, these benefits do not materialise immediately. Investment itself requires materials, labour and financing, and may therefore create inflationary pressures in the short term. It is only once new productive capacity becomes operational that its effects on supply begin to emerge. Even then, greater productivity does not automatically translate into lower prices: much depends on market competition, the strength of demand and how the resulting gains are distributed between firms, workers and consumers.
Despite these limitations, productive investment can still play an important role in promoting price stability. By addressing the structural constraints that limit an economy’s ability to respond to growing demand, it may help reduce inflationary pressures over the longer term.
The point, therefore, is not that investment should replace monetary policy, but rather that the two can complement each other: while monetary policy helps manage demand in the short term, productive investment can strengthen the economy’s ability to meet it over time.
The paradox of monetary tightening
The relationship between inflation and credit reveals a potential paradox.
When a central bank raises interest rates to combat inflation, borrowing becomes more expensive. This tends to discourage consumption and investment, reducing aggregate demand and easing pressure on prices. In the short term, such measures can contribute to disinflation, even when the initial price increases stem from supply-side shocks.
Yet the very same mechanism can also discourage investments that would make the economy more productive and efficient.
Consider a company operating an outdated facility. Investing in new equipment could reduce energy consumption, improve productivity and lower production costs over time. However, if borrowing becomes too expensive, the company may postpone the investment and continue to rely on less efficient technology.
This creates a tension between immediate inflation control and longer-term economic efficiency. Higher interest rates may help contain demand today, while making it more difficult for firms to expand or modernise their productive capacity.
The tension becomes particularly relevant when businesses face rising production costs alongside more expensive financing. At precisely the moment when improving efficiency could help them adapt to higher energy or resource prices, the investment needed to achieve those improvements becomes harder to finance.
Surely this does not mean that higher interest rates ultimately lead to higher inflation; monetary tightening can also help stabilise expectations and prevent temporary price increases from becoming persistent. Nevertheless, its effects on investment and future productive capacity deserve consideration alongside its immediate impact on demand.
The challenge, therefore, is not simply to bring inflation down, but to do so without unnecessarily weakening the economy’s ability to withstand future inflationary pressures.
Why banks prefer borrowers who can provide collateral
Beyond the cost of borrowing, a second, closely related issue concerns how banks decide who receives credit in the first place.
When assessing a loan application, banks must consider the likelihood of repayment. Factors such as income stability, existing assets, collateral and expected cash flows therefore play an important role in their decisions.
An employee with a stable income may offer relatively easy-to-assess repayment capacity, while an entrepreneur seeking to launch a new business, by contrast, may have promising growth prospects but uncertain revenues and insufficient assets to secure financing. Although personal and business loans serve different purposes and involve different risks, this comparison illustrates a broader issue: financial security and productive potential do not always go hand in hand.
From the bank’s perspective, favouring borrowers with reliable income or substantial collateral is perfectly rational. Banks have to manage risk, protect depositors and ensure that their lending activities remain profitable. Yet what makes a loan financially attractive to a bank does not necessarily reflect the broader economic value of the project it finances.
Such financing constraints remain relevant: according to the European Investment Bank, the share of financially constrained European Union firms increased from 6.1% in 2023 to 6.8% in 2024. Part of this difficulty stems from information asymmetries. Banks cannot always determine whether a new business idea is genuinely promising or simply too risky. Collateral therefore provides a way to limit potential losses when a project’s future profitability is uncertain.
However, relying heavily on such guarantees can also disadvantage entrepreneurs whose projects may be economically valuable but whose personal resources are limited. Such information asymmetries can have consequences beyond the requirement for collateral. As Stiglitz and Weiss demonstrated, banks may prefer to deny loans rather than raise interest rates, since higher borrowing costs can attract riskier borrowers or encourage riskier investment decisions. As a result, some potentially productive projects may remain unfunded, even when their promoters are willing to pay more for credit.
This distinction matters because access to credit can influence which economic activities can develop. When lending decisions depend heavily on existing wealth, those who already possess substantial resources may enjoy an advantage, while potentially innovative entrepreneurs without substantial resources struggle to obtain the financing needed to turn their ideas into productive businesses.
The result is a possible tension between financial stability and economic dynamism. A credit system designed to minimise individual lending risks may, in some circumstances, overlook investments capable of generating wider economic benefits.
The question, then, is not whether banks should abandon prudent lending standards, but how the financial system can better identify and support productive opportunities without compromising its stability.
Research and innovation: The economic value of uncertainty
The challenge of risk assessment becomes particularly relevant when it comes to financing research and development.
Unlike established business activities, innovative projects often involve uncertain outcomes and long periods before any commercial return can be expected. Some may never achieve their original objectives, but this does not necessarily mean that the resources invested have been entirely wasted.
Even unsuccessful research can produce valuable knowledge, develop technical expertise, or lead to unexpected solutions benefiting future projects and perhaps the economy as a whole. This creates a particular challenge for the financial system. How can the potential value of an investment be assessed when its results are inherently uncertain and some of its benefits extend beyond the original investor?
Relying too heavily on collateral and predictable cash flows risks overlooking projects with considerable long-term potential. At the same time, uncertainty cannot justify financing every innovative idea. Resources are limited, and investment decisions must still be based on credible assessments of technological feasibility, available expertise and potential applications.
The question is therefore how to evaluate innovative projects without expecting them to meet the same financial criteria as established businesses.
Traditional bank lending may not always be suitable for projects that generate little or no revenue in their early stages. In such cases, alternative forms of financing such as venture capital or staged investment can help address this problem by allowing investors to share risks.
Public support may also play a role, particularly when research generates benefits that private investors cannot fully capture. However, such intervention requires careful project selection, ongoing evaluation and accountability to ensure that public resources are used effectively.
Ultimately, supporting innovation means recognising that economic value cannot always be demonstrated in advance. The challenge is to develop financing mechanisms capable of managing uncertainty without either discouraging promising ideas or abandoning financial discipline.
Related Articles
Here is a list of articles selected by our Editorial Board that have gained significant interest from the public:
Credit has responsibilities beyond the individual contract
A loan is generally understood as an agreement between a bank and a borrower: one provides financing, while the other commits to repay it under the agreed terms. Yet the economic consequences of this transaction can extend far beyond the two parties involved.
Financing a business may contribute to job creation, technological progress and higher productivity. Conversely, failing to finance an economically valuable project may prevent benefits that would have extended to other economic actors, such as firms, workers and consumers.
In this sense, lending decisions shape economic development.
This is particularly relevant when considering how bank credit contributes to money creation. Contrary to the idea that banks simply lend out money previously deposited by savers, commercial banks can create new deposits when they issue loans. These very same deposits provide purchasing power that can be subsequently used for consumption, productive investment, or the acquisition of existing assets.
Credit activity can therefore be said to perform a broader economic function than financial intermediation alone: it helps allocate investment opportunities and, through them, shape the evolution of productive capacity. This does not imply that banks should be forced to finance risky projects or that private profitability should be disregarded. A stable banking system remains essential. However, it suggests the quality of credit allocation deserves greater attention alongside the total volume and cost of lending.
Therefore, supporting productive investment requires more than simply making credit available. It also depends on the ability to evaluate long-term projects, understand technological opportunities and develop financial instruments capable of managing different forms of risk.
A monetary policy that also looks to the future
At this point, the argument leads to a broader question: what relationship should exist between monetary stability and financing economic growth?
The answer cannot be a simple opposition between inflation control and credit expansion. Unrestrained lending growth can fuel excessive demand, financial speculation and inefficient investment; on the other side, prolonged or excessively restricted credit conditions can also discourage investment needed to improve productivity.
The issue therefore concerns not only the quantity of credit, but also its composition and its effects over time.
This longer-term perspective is in fact particularly important. Economic policy may achieve a positive short-term result by reducing demand but at the cost of slowing capital accumulation. Likewise, productive investment may initially increase expenditure but subsequently expand supply capacity. A balanced economic strategy should therefore distinguish between the needs of cyclical stabilisation and those of structural development.
Monetary authorities are responsible for preserving price stability in accordance with their mandates, while banks, investors and public institutions play different roles in financing productive activities and allocating resources. Although these responsibilities are distinct, their economic effects are closely interconnected.
Effective industrial policy can improve productive capacity, while an efficient financial system can help turn innovations into economic activity. Over time, these processes may reduce the economy’s vulnerability to certain supply-side constraints.
The point is not to make productive growth a substitute for monetary stability, but to recognise that price stability depends not only on managing demand, but also on the structural conditions that make supply more flexible and efficient.
Friedman’s true legacy and what remains to be developed
Friedman’s theory retains a fundamental lesson: simply expanding the money supply cannot generate greater wealth indefinitely. Real output ultimately constrains the amount of purchasing power an economy can sustain without generating persistent inflationary pressures.
However, this very principle invites us to consider a dimension that a strictly monetary interpretation tends to leave in the background. If productive capacity plays such an important role in price stability, then the processes through which it develops deserve greater attention.
Money is not merely a means of purchasing goods and services that already exist; through credit, it can also help finance the formation of capital that will make future production possible. This introduces an important distinction between immediate purchasing power and long-term productive effects.
Credit used primarily to finance current expenditure may have different implications from credit directed towards capital accumulation or technological development. While both can stimulate demand in the short term, productive investment may also expand future output and reduce production costs.
This distinction brings together three issues, often considered separately: price stability, credit allocation and economic growth. By determining which projects receive financing, banks and other financial intermediaries influence not only individual economic activities but also the development of the productive system.
This does not mean that lenders should ignore risk but rather highlights the importance of developing expertise and financial instruments to identify and support investments whose value emerges over time, even when they lack substantial collateral or predictable revenues.
Economic policy must therefore take these relationships into account when seeking to contain inflation without undermining long term development. The quantity of money remains important, but so does understanding how credit is allocated, what productive capacity it helps create and how these decisions shape the economy’s future.
Going beyond Friedman therefore does not mean denying the role of money in inflation but recognising that lasting price stability also depends on the productive capacity of the economy and on the financial decisions that help shape it.
Ultimately, economic stability is not only about preventing demand from growing faster than supply. It is also about creating the conditions for supply to expand, innovate and become more efficient.
Editor’s Note: The opinions expressed here by the authors are their own, not those of Impakter.com — Cover Photo Credit: Tanha Tamanna Syed.



